Stripe vs. PayPal Invoice Fees: Full US Card and ACH Costs
If you send a client a $1,000 invoice, is Stripe or PayPal cheaper?
It looks like a simple comparison of two rates. But when we checked the official pricing, one detail stood out: Stripe charges separately for payment processing and its invoicing product. Comparing Stripe's card rate with PayPal's invoice rate alone leaves out part of the cost.
We used the same invoice amounts to calculate both card and bank payment fees. All figures are calculations based on published rates. We explain how to choose between the options and include official sources and a verification date so you can check the numbers yourself.
The quick answer: what does a $1,000 invoice actually cost?
First, here are the assumptions:
- The seller has a US business account, the payer is also in the US, and the invoice is for USD $1,000.
- Stripe uses Invoicing Starter for a one-time invoice paid through the hosted invoice page, without manually entering card details.
- PayPal uses Invoicing, with separate calculations for its standard card, PayPal wallet and Pay by Bank payment options.
- We exclude international surcharges, currency conversion, taxes, refunds, disputes, custom pricing and optional subscriptions.
- Fees use published rates and are shown to two decimal places. Your payment provider's account statement determines the actual charges.
| Payment option | Processing fee | Invoicing product fee | Total fees | Net from $1,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe Invoicing Starter + US card | $29.30 | $4.00 | $33.30 | $966.70 |
| PayPal Invoicing + standard credit/debit card | $30.39 | $0.00* | $30.39 | $969.61 |
| Stripe Invoicing Starter + ACH Direct Debit | $5.00 | $4.00 | $9.00 | $991.00 |
| PayPal Invoicing + Pay by Bank (ACH) | $10.00 | $0.00* | $10.00 | $990.00 |
| PayPal Invoicing + PayPal wallet/Checkout | $35.39 | $0.00* | $35.39 | $964.61 |
* Standard PayPal invoicing does not add a per-invoice product fee like Stripe Invoicing Starter. The optional $14.99/month Invoicing Subscription is excluded and is not required to send ordinary invoices. [1][2][3][4]
At the $1,000 invoice amount:
- If the customer pays online using the standard US card option, PayPal costs $2.91 less than Stripe Starter.
- For eligible bank payments, Stripe Starter costs $1.00 less than PayPal Pay by Bank.
- If the PayPal customer chooses wallet/Checkout instead of the standard card option, the fee becomes $35.39. Funding a payment with a card does not necessarily mean it receives the standard card product rate.
Why can comparing only 2.9% and 2.99% lead to the wrong choice?
Stripe's 2.9% + $0.30 covers payment processing only
Stripe's standard US online card rate is 2.9% + $0.30. But we are using Invoicing Starter, which adds 0.4% for each paid one-time invoice. Invoicing Plus charges 0.5% instead. [1][2]
This comparison covers sending an invoice first, then collecting payment. Stripe Checkout's pricing for generating an invoice or receipt after payment applies to a different workflow. Its cap cannot simply be applied to Invoicing Starter. [5]
PayPal invoice card, wallet and ACH payments have different rates
PayPal publishes these main domestic invoice payment rates in the US: [3][4]
| PayPal invoice payment option | Published rate used here |
|---|---|
| Standard credit/debit cards, Apple Pay and other eligible card payments | 2.99% + $0.49 |
| PayPal Checkout/wallet, Venmo and the corresponding options | 3.49% + $0.49 |
| Pay Later | 4.99% + $0.49 |
| Pay by Bank (ACH) | 1%, capped at $10 per transaction |
Calculation 1: breaking down every fee on $1,000
Stripe Invoicing Starter: $33.30 for a card payment
There are two separate charges:
Processing fee = $1,000 × 2.9% + $0.30 = $29.30
Invoicing fee = $1,000 × 0.4% = $4.00
Total = $29.30 + $4.00 = $33.30
Net received = $1,000 - $33.30 = $966.70
Treating Stripe's 2.9% + $0.30 as the entire invoice cost understates the fee by $4.00. That is the main mistake this article aims to prevent.
PayPal Invoicing: $30.39 for standard cards, $35.39 for the wallet
For the same amount, we calculate the two payment products separately:
Standard card fee = $1,000 × 2.99% + $0.49 = $30.39
Standard card net = $1,000 - $30.39 = $969.61
PayPal wallet fee = $1,000 × 3.49% + $0.49 = $35.39
PayPal wallet net = $1,000 - $35.39 = $964.61
These two PayPal invoice options differ by $5.00. So we do not use one blanket "PayPal invoice rate": we first check which option the customer actually uses.
Stripe ACH: a $5 cap does not mean the whole invoice costs $5
Stripe ACH Direct Debit's base processing fee is 0.8%, capped at $5 per transaction. On $1,000, 0.8% is $8, so the cap reduces the processing fee to $5. But the $4.00 Invoicing Starter fee still applies.
ACH processing = min($1,000 × 0.8%, $5) = $5.00
Invoicing fee = $1,000 × 0.4% = $4.00
Total = $5.00 + $4.00 = $9.00
Net received = $1,000 - $9.00 = $991.00
If the payment also uses paid Financial Connections verification, published pricing lists a possible extra $1.50 per verification. Under that assumption, the fee rises from $9.00 to $10.50, which is $0.50 more than PayPal's $10. We do not assume every ACH payment incurs this charge; it depends on the verification method used. [6]
PayPal Pay by Bank: capped at $10 per transaction
Pay by Bank fee = min($1,000 × 1%, $10) = $10.00
Net received = $1,000 - $10.00 = $990.00
One name can cause confusion: PayPal also publishes ACH Services pricing for different products and approval requirements. Here we compare only Pay by Bank paid through a PayPal invoice. Another ACH product's price cannot be substituted for it.
Calculation 2: does the result hold from $100 to $5,000?
Looking only at $1,000 might suggest "PayPal for cards, Stripe for bank payments" is always right. We recalculated fees at four invoice amounts.
| Invoice amount | Stripe Starter + card | PayPal invoice + standard card | Stripe Starter + ACH | PayPal invoice + Pay by Bank |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $100 | $3.60 | $3.48 | $1.20 | $1.00 |
| $500 | $16.80 | $15.44 | $6.00 | $5.00 |
| $1,000 | $33.30 | $30.39 | $9.00 | $10.00 |
| $5,000 | $165.30 | $149.99 | $25.00 | $10.00 |
Two points stand out.
Stripe's 0.4% invoicing fee matters more as the amount grows
On a $5,000 card invoice, Stripe's processing fee is $145.30 and the invoicing product adds $20.00, for a total of $165.30. PayPal's standard card option costs $149.99 at the published base rate, a difference of $15.31.
This is not a final quote for every Stripe business. If you have negotiated custom pricing or use a product other than Invoicing Starter, recalculate using your own agreement.
Larger ACH invoices do not always make Stripe cheaper
Stripe's ACH processing fee stops at $5, but its 0.4% invoicing fee does not stop there. PayPal Pay by Bank's transaction fee in this scenario is capped at $10. With these published rates:
- On a $500 bank payment, PayPal costs $1 less.
- On a $1,000 bank payment, Stripe costs $1 less.
- On a $5,000 bank payment, PayPal costs $15 less.
Calculation 3: what is the difference on 30 monthly invoices of $1,000?
A difference of $1 to $3 per payment may sound small. We modeled a month of invoices to see what it could mean for a business.
Assumptions: one US business sends and successfully collects 30 one-time invoices of $1,000 each in a month. 18 are paid with standard US credit cards and 12 with the respective ACH payment option. All use the base fees in this article, with no extra paid verification, refunds, disputes or international payments.
| Cost item | Stripe Starter | PayPal Invoicing |
|---|---|---|
| 18 card invoices | $599.40 | $547.02 |
| 12 ACH invoices | $108.00 | $120.00 |
| Total monthly fees | $707.40 | $667.02 |
| Amount left from $30,000 invoiced | $29,292.60 | $29,332.98 |
With this payment mix, PayPal's total base fees are $40.38 lower.
Now change all 30 invoices to $1,000 ACH payments:
Stripe Starter: 30 × $9 = $270
PayPal Pay by Bank: 30 × $10 = $300
Difference: Stripe costs $30 less
For the same business, changing only the payment-method mix can reverse the result.
Which other fees are easy to miss?
Stripe Plus and PayPal's optional subscription use different billing units
Stripe Invoicing Plus lists 0.5% per paid invoice, rather than Starter's 0.4%. On $1,000, the invoicing charge alone rises from $4 to $5. [1]
PayPal lists an optional Invoicing Subscription at $14.99/month. That does not mean adding $14.99 to every ordinary PayPal invoice. If your account uses the subscription, spread its cost across your total monthly invoices when comparing costs. [4]
Sending an invoice and issuing proof of payment are different workflows
Stripe Checkout has separate pricing for post-payment invoices, including a cap that differs from this Invoicing Starter scenario. It does not follow that the same cap applies when you send a $5,000 payment request with Invoicing Starter. [5]
Before calculating, identify the workflow: are you requesting payment first, or collecting payment and then issuing a document? The features and charges can differ.
Cross-border payments, conversion and manually entered cards cost extra
These tables cover only standard US domestic USD scenarios. For example, Stripe lists additional pricing for international cards, currency conversion and manually entered card details. PayPal also adds an international fee to cross-border invoices. [2][4]
If your customer is in the UK, Canada or another market, do not simply reuse the $1,000 results above. First check the seller's account region, buyer's region, card issuing country, invoice currency and who handles conversion. Our international payment fee guide is a starting point; then check your provider's actual quote.
ACH timing, failures and verification also affect costs
Bank payment fees are only part of the decision. Stripe's ACH Direct Debit information describes longer confirmation and settlement times and possible Financial Connections verification fees. [6]
If you need to ship goods, activate a service or pay suppliers immediately, settlement timing also affects cash flow. Failed debits, disputes, refunds and subscription billing are outside this base comparison and need a separate assessment.
How would we choose for a freelancer or small business?
Start with three figures from a recent batch of actual invoices: average amount, payment-method mix and extra fees. Then compare using the formulas in this article.
If most of your US customers pay invoices using the standard card option, PayPal is cheaper in the $1,000 example at these published rates. If most make eligible bank payments around $1,000, Stripe Starter's base cost is slightly lower, but paid verification can change that. For larger bank invoices, recalculate with PayPal's $10 cap in mind.
Check whether your customers can and will use the option, whether you have custom pricing, and what other product fees appear on your statement. These simulations do not tell us payment success rates or customer preferences.
Recalculate your own invoices
Merchant Fee Calc offers two different tools:
- Stripe vs. PayPal base payment fee comparison: compare basic US domestic card and PayPal Checkout costs first. Its results do not mean Stripe Invoicing product fees are included.
- PayPal Invoice Fee Calculator: choose PayPal, standard cards, Pay Later or Pay by Bank to calculate fees, net receipts or the invoice amount needed for a target net receipt.
To reproduce the complete Stripe invoice workflow here, use these simplified formulas and replace the rates with those for your account:
Stripe Starter + standard US online card:
Total fee = amount × 2.9% + $0.30 + amount × 0.4%
Stripe Starter + ACH Direct Debit:
Total fee = min(amount × 0.8%, $5) + amount × 0.4%
+ optional verification fees actually incurred
PayPal invoice + standard card:
Total fee = amount × 2.99% + $0.49
PayPal invoice + Pay by Bank:
Total fee = min(amount × 1%, $10)
Use the same invoice amount for each calculation. Do not assume one payment method and then mistake its fee for the average across all payments.
Frequently asked questions
Does Stripe Invoicing Starter's 0.4% include card processing?
No. The official pricing we checked lists 0.4% per paid invoice, with Stripe Payments fees charged separately. The standard US $1,000 card invoice here costs $33.30 in total, not just $29.30. [1][2]
Do I need to pay a monthly fee to create and send PayPal invoices?
You can create and send ordinary PayPal invoices, generally paying the relevant transaction fee when a customer pays through the invoice. PayPal also offers an optional Invoicing Subscription at $14.99/month. We do not automatically add it to each ordinary invoice. [3][4]
If Stripe ACH is capped at $5, why does this article show $9?
The $5 cap applies to the ACH Direct Debit processing fee per transaction. We also use Invoicing Starter, which adds $4 to the $1,000 paid invoice, making $9 in total. Add any paid bank verification charges actually incurred. [1][6]
Are PayPal Pay by Bank and PayPal ACH Services the same thing?
We do not treat them as the same price offering. This article uses Pay by Bank (ACH) within PayPal Invoicing: 1%, capped at $10 per transaction. Other PayPal products may have different ACH rates and approval requirements. [4]
Can I use these figures for international invoices or currencies other than USD?
No. This article is limited to US domestic USD payments. International surcharges, conversion and local payment methods affect the final cost. Confirm your account country and actual payment option, then recalculate using the relevant market's fee schedule. [2][4]
Conclusion: compare the whole invoice, not one line of pricing
The calculations make one point clear: Stripe Invoicing costs more than Stripe Payments processing alone, and PayPal Invoicing does not charge every payment method the same rate.
For the $1,000 US domestic baseline, PayPal's standard card fee is $30.39 and Stripe Starter's card fee is $33.30. Bank payments cost $10.00 and $9.00, respectively. The cheaper option can change with the amount, payment mix or paid verification.
Recalculate using your own invoice records and matching assumptions. Saving a dollar or two per invoice should not overshadow customer payment habits, settlement timing or actual product limits.
Sources and calculation notes
Verified on October 29, 2026. We used official US public pricing accessible on that date. Tables model standard rates, with each fee component displayed in US dollars and cents. Actual rounding and product eligibility depend on your account.
- Stripe Invoicing pricing: Starter 0.4%, Plus 0.5%
- Stripe Payments pricing: US domestic online cards, international cards and conversion
- PayPal US Invoicing and payment-method pricing
- PayPal US merchant fees: Invoicing, Pay by Bank, optional subscription and international fees
- Stripe Checkout: post-payment invoices have separate pricing
- Stripe US ACH Direct Debit: 0.8%/$5 cap and Financial Connections verification fees
Merchant Fee Calc compiled and recalculated this article using public pricing rules. Providers may change prices or offer account-specific agreements. Your account agreement and transaction records determine the actual charges.